Saturday, April 29, 2006

Illegal immigration

I recently stumbled across this blog, which is penned by someone who is well-educated (PhD) and has an interest in things philosophical. So naturally, I thought I'd take issue with something he said.

Many of the posts on this blog (in fact, probably most) have to do with the topic of illegal immigration. Here are some excerpts(although I would encourage those who have the time to go over there and read the posts in full):


...we are told of the "basic human rights" of the illegal immigrant.

But what rights are these? Do they include the right to invade a sovereign nation and violate its laws? There is no right to be granted citizenship; it is privilege foreign-born persons must apply for. It is true that we are a nation of immigrants. But it is false that we are a nation of illegal immigrants.



There are certain actions, such as crossing the border without permission, that reasonable people deem unacceptable. So these actions are made illegal. These laws are reasonable and just and every country has them. So what do the good bishops propose? They would change the laws so that these very same unacceptable actions are no longer accounted illegal.

(samples quoted from here)


Let me first start by noting that there are a lot of 'easy comebacks' to this man's position which could be offered by those who disagree with him (for example, one might note that in whatever form the previous indigenous inhabitants of North America had a legal system, it would be hard to construe that it provided for large groups of people to attack and kill them and take over their land). However, what is possibly a little more intricate(and also much more valuable) would be to point out the fundamental mistakes that this man is making in his implicit and explicit assumptions.


To begin with I would question this blogger's assertion that "There are certain actions, such as crossing the border without permission, that reasonable people deem unacceptable." In its unclarified form, this statement is entirely untenable. If the blogger himself were to awake one day and find that his home had been neatly cordoned off and made a separate country so that a border existed around it, and that he was not to be permitted under any circumstances to cross it, I am certain that he would question the validity of this assertion in an amount of time less than or equal to the time that his groceries would last.

It is clear, then, that there are some borders which one ought to be able to cross without permission(such as the boundaries of one's home). Thus, this blogger must be inferring that some sort of non-arbitrary reason is in force for certain particular borders as regards his assertion. It would be improper of me to assume outright that I know what that reason is, but a clue might be given in his repeated use of the phrase 'a sovereign nation' throughout his blog. I think it would be fair to suggest that this blogger believes 'sovereign nations' have a degree of validity with regards to enforcement of their borders that arbitrary institutions or authorities do not have, such as if I personally were to define a border around this man's house.

So what is a sovereign nation? Dictionary.com defines sovereign as adj. Self-governing; independent: a sovereign state. So, is the implicit assumption of this blogger that having a community which is self-governing and independent gives it validity in asserting the requirement of permission over its borders? Again, we need only to turn to the possibility of being contained within one's own house to note the untenability of such an assertion. The simple fact of his neighbours organising themselves in a self-governing fashion would surely not be sufficient to allow them to doom this man to a slow death, would it? Perhaps a mere organisation of neighbours has not met the requirements for 'nation'? Let us then extend our little thought-experiment to the case in which this man's state were to organise and implement such a border. Would this then become a situation that the man (who, we assume, is a 'reasonable person') would deem acceptable? Perhaps neither of these situations suffice for our requirement of 'independent'? Then let us make the last and predictable step of extending our hypothetical to the situation in which this man's entire country cordons him off. It seems clear there is no change in our result.

It may be, however(and I think it is likely), that we have incorrectly determined the source of authority intended by the blogger for the establishment and traversal control of a border. I now venture a little further into the ether, but I would suggest there is a subtle implication in some of the bloggers comments that citizenship in his country is sort of like membership in a very special club which citizens have earned, and therefore it is unethical for others who have not earned that membership to take by their own means the benefits offered to those members. This blogger might say that the reason his own country would be unreasonable in cordoning him off from it is that he is a citizen of that country, and thus entitled not to be cut off from it. Lest this become a discussion of the concept of citizenship, let us suppose for the moment that this basis for enforcement of a border holds, since we are near to the definition of a citizen itself.

Finally, we can ask the question that is most pertinent to this discussion: is it fair? By which I mean, is it fair for there to be such a club which allows or denies membership and then enforces that membership strictly? Obviously, there is nothing inherently unfair in the existence of such an institution. However, the manner in which membership is determined may be executed in an unfair manner, i.e. under the influence of prejudice. Also, the actions of the club as an organisation may be unethical, although that is a different order altogether. So, how can we determine if prejudice is a relevant problem in our scenario? Well, a far greater wedge of 'reasonable people' than our good friend presented earlier might be inclined to agree with the assertion that such an institution is fair if any person who satisfies the requirements for membership is allowed to be a member, and if all are given equal opportunity to satisfy those requirements. It is at this point that we come to the essential point at which I personally would deny the 'fairness' of the institution in question: it is not in fact the case with this man's country that all are given equal opportunity to satisfy the requirements of membership. In most cases, what the citizens of this man's country have done to gain membership is simply to have been born into membership. Immediately and without any further forbearance, these people have been accepted for membership, whereas no matter what any person does who was born in another country, they are incapable of 'going back' and changing their selection of which country to be born in. Just as a human being is unable to select his or her skin colour, these people have no opportunity to fulfill the most common requirement of this man's country for citizenship: place of birth. If there were indeed legitimate requirements fairly levied against all would-be citizens of this man's country, including those born within it, such as personal contribution or something similar, which if not met would result in the refussal of acceptance equally in all cases, then we could say that this situation is fair. However, a situation which discriminates between people based on something they cannot choose or control, especially a situation having significant relevance for their health, well-being, and livelihood, cannot be called fair.

Phishing the murky depths

I've received a fair number of phishing attempts in my time, but this one beats them all on several accounts(read on to find out why I didn't even report it to Google!)


I have a new email address!
You can now email me at: [removed so you won't]

Dear Sir/madam,




US$250 million Dollar Agricultural Grant For Farmers and Ranchers





We offer Agricultural Grant of US$250 million dollar for Farmers and Ranchers from National Department of Agriculture (NDA) This Grant is for Experienced farmers and ranchers who are unable to obtain financing from commercial credit sources.


Loan amounts range from $ $2,000,000.00 to $100,000,000.00 and $100,000,000.00 to $250,000,000.00 (amount varies based on Applicant capability).


United Nation Development Project (UNDP) in Africa is the sponsor of this facility.


REASON FOR CONTACTING YOU:


My name is Dr. Thomas Quam and I am the Director of Farm Operations in the National Department of Agriculture (NDA). I need your assistance to hold on my behalf the sum of $4.5Million, which has been allocated to unexisting Farmer. It is my entire plan to have this done so that I can benefit from this opportunity.


YOU ROLE:


I will present you as foreign representatives to some of the farmers and Ranchers in charge of procuring imported farm equipments. so as to obtain clearance from the UNDP fund clearance office here. As soon as the clearance is obtained then the sum of $4.5Million will be transferred to you and all the records will be destroyed leaving no trace of the transaction.


YOUR GAIN:


You will be compensated with the sum of $1Million for your role in this transaction. If you are interested, please send your Names, Phone and fax number, your physical address, On receipt of this information I will call you immediately to clarify areas you are in doubt.


Expecting your response.


Yours faithfully,

Dr. Thomas Quam

Director, Operations

NDA.






- Thomas Quam


First of all, this little sucker actually managed to slip through Gmail's filter. That's a pretty incredible feat. In the entire time I've had my gmail account, I've had maybe 10 spams/phishers get through, and most of those by totally obfuscating their own message. Impressive!

Second of all, note that this phisher is inviting you to defraud a UNDP development project for farmers in legitimate need!! Can you believe this!

Third, note the incredible candor of someone(albeit a character in the scam) who is risking their job and their name to rip off the aid organisation they work for: "It is my entire plan to have this done so that I can benefit from this opportunity." Wow, no mincing words here.

Fourth, note that this character suggests actually convincing real farmers to allow the money to go overseas and then sticking it to them and running off!


My conclusion(and the reason I didn't report it)? Anyone evil enough to be drawn in by this scam absolutely one hundred percent deserves to lose as much money as they are willing to put up!!! If phishing switches over to this kind of mode in general I have to say we might not want to get rid of it!

Monday, April 24, 2006

the end is now

For along time, a standard component of my war on the current intellectual property system has been to point out how incredibly absurd our current laws will appear when computers can, with very little direction, churn out patentable and copyrightable material. That day is now. Popular Science has an article on a man(John Koza) who is using what is, at its heart, an incredibly simple machine(if composed of about 1000 cpu's) to brute-force new ideas until an 'innovative' one is found. One such idea has actually been successfully patented, one of the first ever patents granted to a machine designer(in reality, of course, the patent was granted to the human who uses the machine).

What if(as is likely within a short period of time) your average Joe has a computer of this power factor in his home and is able to run a similar program on it? Who gets the intellectual 'property' that is 'produced' by it? Does credit go to the program's designer, or to the man who typed in "find a good engine design, please, mr. computer."???? The natural progression of technology in this area will quickly blow our existing intellectual property system to shreds. Don't believe me? Take note of this: before designing the optical lense that was ultimately patented, Koza's beowulf cluster duplicated scores of already patented designs by starting from simple parameters with a simple goal(at no time was any portion of these designs in any way inputted). It seems patent offices everywhere are going to be scrambling to do the one thing I've been pointing out they are unable to do: define what exactly 'obvious' actually is.

Patent laws require patentable ideas to be 'non-obvious.' What that actually means nobody has the foggiest clue. Is a design obvious if a simple computer program can generate it automatically given a basic understanding of the target context? How about a complex program? How about a complex program run on a complex machine? How about a complex program run on a complex machine that is in everybody's offices and homes? The reality is that without the ability to pick and choose individually who will receive the incredible economic incentive that our intellectual 'property' laws actually are(and in most cases what we need here is a good weeding) our current patent and copyright laws are fundamentally meaningless. Unless we can redefine the transfer of intellectual 'property' as the service it actually is, our entire system of intellectual 'property' law is likely to end up in the biggest mess we've ever seen.

Saturday, April 22, 2006

everything you need to know

I had this idea the other day to search for a common phrase that people use for lots of different topics on google and see what kind of results I would get, as a kind of cross section of the web. I selected the phrase 'everything you need to know' and my results were fabulous! In order, here were the first few topics the results had 'everything you need to know' about:

vampires
the giant panda
caffeine
babies
Lupus
travel
investing
space
job-seeking
Tiger OS for Mac
solid foods
spreadsheets
elk hunting
charity

item 15 was an episode from discovery channel entitled simply 'everything you need to know.' Nothing could top the very next entry, however, which stated in unequivocal terms:

No Episode with that information

Tuesday, March 14, 2006

Swarmcast Accelerator: what it is and why you should have it!

What is it?
Swarmcast Accelerator is a new, free product from Onion Networks which is magically capable of accelerating and improving the download of pretty much anything on the internet.

How does it work?
Swarmcast Accelerator uses a technology called swarmstreaming to redistribute the bandwidth necessary to download a file across all the people who are currently downloading it. Instead of all the information coming directly from one computer which is providing the file on the internet, much of this information is shared between the computers downloading the file so that all these computers can cumulatively receive the information much faster than if the first computer tried to send individual copies of all this information to each of the other computers all by itself.

This is, in fact, the concept used by all peer-to-peer programs. Swarmstreaming is different in one essential way, however, from all other programs to date. Instead of receiving different parts of a file in whatever random order they can be found, the process is specially coordinated so that the file arrives in perfect order, just like a regular download. That way, you can start to use the file, or play it if it is a media file, immediately without waiting for it to finish. Until now, this was the main superiority that regular internet downloads had over peer-to-peer downloads.

Why should anyone use it?
Alright, so this program sounds interesting, but why should anyone use it? This is only a marginal improvement over other peer-to-peer systems and who wants to deal with a specialised program and limited content?

This is where Swarmcast Accelerator really shines. Unlike other peer-to-peer systems, after the initial installation there are no special programs to run and no special network to use for files. The Swarmcast Accelerator meshes right in to your existing browser and can accelerate any file on the existing internet. It helps take the burden of large files on the internet and distribute it among the people who want those files, making online distribution of pretty much anything much more cost effective for everyone. And what's the net effect of this for the user? The internet simply starts to work magically faster.

Swarmstreaming is a technology that I've been waiting for for a long time, and I'm overjoyed that it's finally here. Congratulations, Onion Networks, for your amazing work. Now, everybody go here and download this program right now!

If you have more questions about Swarmstreaming technology, Onion Networks has more information here.

Wednesday, March 01, 2006

They don't call it theft, actually

The BBC got called on their error when they claimed on the air that filesharing, specifically copyright infringement, is theft. Hear their laudable and surprisingly transparent recovery here which notes, among other things, that

File sharing is not theft. It has never been theft. Anyone who says it is theft is wrong and has unthinkingly absorbed too many Recording Industry Association of America press releases. We know that script line was wrong. It was a mistake. We're very, very sorry.


Here's the paragraph for which I particularly applaud them, though:

Railways and canals

Now we've got that out the way, let us ask you a question. Why is it that every time the media starts to talk about the internet they feel compelled to bang on about paedophiles and terrorists and generally come over like a cross between Joe McCarthy and the Childcatcher from Chitty Chitty Bang Bang?

Well here's one answer - it sells copy. Another answer is that we're totally scared of new media, because new media is railways and we're canals, and you all just know how that's going to end.

So we seek to equate the internet with all bad things to scare you off it. At some corporate freudian level, there's some truth to that accusation.


They ultimately retreat to the position that if filesharing goes encrypted the flood of encrypted traffic will prevent the government from effectively monitoring what goes on on the internet and baddies will be impossible to track.

I hear their point, but I think it's still a little misguided. First of all, any criminal worth catching is using some serious encryption. Now of course, much of this is still breakable by law enforcement, but it takes a huge amount of time and processing power, and given that many non-criminals(in fact, probasbly far more than criminals)use strong encryption for business or personal reasons it is probably already beyond feasibility for the government(s) to be monitoring strongly encrypted data at present.

Secondly, these people don't seem to understand how much encryption is already in use. Every time someone accesses a bank online, every time someone uses a secure website or any secure method of sending email, IM's, or files, and in the case of many games played online(to prevent cheating)there is encryption going on. Unless the governments of our various countries can afford more processing power than all the regular users in the world put together, it is fairly unlikely that they are able to monitor even the loosely encrypted communication going on over the web.

Most importantly, however, they have missed the primary point: the vast majority of encryption is not done for nefarious means. The reason ecnryption is so available is that it does have so many legitimate uses in generally making information processing and transfer mor effective. In the online world of a decade ago, this concern might have been relevant, but today it's simply not realistic. Ultimately, this concern is totally misplaced. The secure online world came and went a long time ago with pgp and similar technologies, and anyone who hasn't realised that is living in the past.

Wednesday, January 25, 2006

Google--good at search, bad at censorship

I'm not sure if this is good news or bad news, so I'll just fill you in and let you decide:

There has been a lot of hubbub recently over Google's creation of a self-censored search option(www.google.cn) for tightly restricted China, such as here.

Curious to see how this censorship would work in practice, I chose a suggested topic of controversy, "Falun Gong" and headed over to check it out. My first result was:

Falun Dafa & Falun Gong - [ 翻译此页 BETA ]
Falun Dafa and Falun Gong: what they are and why the Chinese government is terrified of them.
www.religioustolerance.org/falungong.htm - 14k - 网页快照 - 类似网页



hmmmm. Personally, I might have censored that. Clicking on the page I quickly found tidbits like these:

"The movement has experienced horrendous levels of persecution in China."


and

"The Chinese government has relentlessly suppressed religious groups since achieving power in 1949. The rest of the world is most familiar with its oppression of non-registered Christian groups. However, the government has also persecuted many types of new religious and spiritual groups, including the Falun Gong. In fact, its suppression extends beyond such groups to include organizations that teach only simple meditation and gymnastic techniques. The government appears to fear any national group that is capable of organizing its followers into direct action"



hmmmm. Again, I might have censored that.


I guess Google just needs a little more practice at not giving you the information you're looking for.

Wednesday, January 18, 2006










Sunday
Night, January 29th


the
place to be is the



OSBORNE
VILLAGE FREEHOUSE

for


Chelsea
Crawford's
CD Release Party

debuting
the album
THE
MASQUERADE

Doors
@ 8pm (No Cover)


This
will be an evening of great live music, including international
musicians,


great
food, drinks and lots of friends.


(If
you and your party would like a table you need to make reservations,
the place will fill up fast!)

 

 


"Chelsea's
music is lush and rich.  Listening to it, my immediate reaction
was that she has dusted off sultry jazz and brought it into the 21 st

 century. To my ears, her compositions are both nostalgic and
contemporary. ….   She's taken all that's good about
older jazz standards and somehow updated it for a new listening
audience. I kept thinking, this sounds 'new' to me."


                                                                         
  Nigel Moore of Café 100.7 - Winnipeg




Wednesday, January 04, 2006

This just in...and out!

Are you unhappy in your current job and wish you could earn a better living? Stratford Career Institute can offer you the perfect solution!

Honest, I swear!

They sent me a neat little letter and told me all about it. They must be really busy with all the people they're helping to become millionaires, because they even forgot to put my name on the envelope. They must know me, though, because their letter begins, "Dear Friend" and I'm not generally friends with people I don't know.

Because they had been kind enough to send me an exciting, albeit impersonal piece of undirected advertising, I did to them what I try to do to all my friends: I returned the favour. They had included a prepaid return envelope, so it was easy. I have plenty of advertising material sitting around, so I grabbed the closest piece and slipped it in. On the front it reads:

"Cremation. You might think it's the last decision you have to make..."

and on the back:

"What you don't know could make all the difference..."

Just to keep everything square, it too has a postage-paid tear-off reply option. It's going in the mail tomorrow. I don't know how my career has improved as a result of this letter, but I can certainly tell you my happiness has.

Thursday, December 29, 2005

Just some extra information

By the way, although I didn't originally go out looking for stuff like this, I've gone to the trouble of tracking down some links and information people might find interesting.

There are other people out there of note promoting similar ideas to mine on filesharing, like Robert Hamilton, a professor on internet law at Ohio State, contrary to the suggestions in a recent debate that no one out there is promoting alternate views on filesharing. He was mentioned briefly at

http://www.news.cornell.edu/Chronicle/03/11.6.03/filesharing_debate.html

Or, take a look at the ideas of Professor Larry Lessig of Stanford at

http://news-service.stanford.edu/news/2004/march17/fileshare-317.html

Not to mention, of course, the entire Open Source Culture movement.

Also, here are some sources that, whether they are right or not, share my interpretation of the Canadian ruling on filesharing:

http://news.com.com/2100-1027_3-5182641.html?tag=st_pop
-"In a far-ranging decision, the court further found that both downloading music and putting it in a shared folder available to other people online appeared to be legal in Canada."

http://www.webuser.co.uk/news/48323.html
-"A Canadian judge has dealt a blow to the global record industry's anti-piracy campaign by declaring that sharing music over the internet is not illegal"

http://www.globetechnology.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20051208.gtjkcolumndec8/BNStory/Technology/
-"that activity is still legal in Canada"

and finally,

http://www.mondaq.com/i_article.asp_Q_articleid_E_36846
-"The motions judge held that, with reference to subsection 80(1) of the Act, downloading a song for personal use does not amount to infringement. He also said that placing personal copies of songs onto shared directories, such that the songs were accessible by other computer users over the Internet, did not amount to authorization or distribution contrary to the Act."

Abstract concepts as services instead of property

Someone posted the following comment:


Anonymous said...

Please elaborate on how services are treated differently from property under the law and why you think intellectual property would be more aptly administered as intellectual service? In exactly what way would this be an improvement?

7:30 PM


Certainly. The main difference between property and services under the law is that property can be 'rented', whereas services are either performed or not, and any future actions resulting from the performance of services without rental of property do not necessarily need to be controlled by law.

The reasons I think this would be an immense improvement are many. One is that it is much easier to enforce a model based on treating intellectual 'property' as a service. Currently we have very complex models for trying to describe intellectual property in ways which differ from tangible property such as having expiry times on patents, allowances for 'fair use' requiring legal judgments on 'artistic value' and the 'obviousness' of abstract concepts, uncertain status of intellectual property between jurisdictions, unclear action in the case of simultaneous discoveries, punishment for coincidental but not derivative innovations, etc. By contrast, when describing intellectual 'property' as a service, all this complicated law can be boiled down to a simple economic incentive program where the government allows a certain entity the exclusive right to perform a service, or, in the event that such an incentive is deemed unnecessary, research can be funded by private entities with vested interests in the results or by donations after the fact from people who benefit from the innovation, all of which is simple to legislate and enforce. By contrast, when viewing abstract ideas as 'property' one is forced to try and monitor, for example, all data transferred over the internet, or all communications between people, which is not a feasible task.

An important feature of this new structure would be that the government would be able to remove these incentive programs in areas where they are no longer necessary to encourage innovation: for example in the area of computer software where technological advancements will soon render the human programmer an irrellevant component. Currently, because all intellectual 'property' is treated the same, the government is forced to spend enormous resources essentially enforcing private entities' particular business models' viabilities when in fact some of those models may be ready to be replaced in the market because of their inefficiency. These alternate models may be much better suited to a digital, interconnected world but currently we have no mechanism for selectively targeting our incentives in the areas that need the most development.

Possibly the most important advantage would be that treating the transfer of abstract ideas as a service rather than a transfer of property is much better suited to the digital world, which is becoming increasingly important as computers become part of every part of our lives. From a computational perspective, there is no difference between a mechanic reconfiguring the parts of a car from a less useful state, say where it doesn't drive around, to a more useful state where it does, and a programmer reconfiguring a computer from a less useful state, say where it can't manipulate text documents, to a more useful state where it does. The same thinking, in the language of the digital world, would apply to a builder reconfiguring a pile of raw materials into a house, or a doctor reconfiguring a person with a badly broken leg into a person with a good chance of recovery. Thinking in the language of information theory, it is easy to see that the idea of services translates well to the application of intellectual 'property' and that the idea of education, or teaching, translates well to the transfer of abstract concepts. When a student learns something in school, they are allowed to tell other people about those things. In the same way, unless the government chose to intervene with an incentive program or something, when information is transferred to a person or their computer, it would be their choice as to whether or not to 'teach' it to another person or their computer. The difference in the digital world? Computers are much better and faster at 'learning' from each other than humans are. Think of the benefit to society.

Another important note is that treating intellectual 'property' like this would help ease the problem of transferring abstract ideas, such as software, to developing nations where people cannot afford the premiums we currently charge. This would no doubt speed industrialization of these regions, significantly boosting the world economy.

Finally, as an aside to any and all critics, I am reasonably convinced that any sort of 'protection' currently offered for intellectual 'property' could be easily implemented under this alternate system if it was deemed necessary or useful to the function of society. It would, however, be much simpler in law and in enforcement, if one can manage to put up with such a difficult inconvenience.

Wednesday, December 28, 2005

Filesharing: the debate part 2 (the end?)

Jeff: I would normally enjoy a debate on this or any other topic. And I do appreciate your determination to be civil and respectful: kudos. BUT...it is a waste of my time and frankly angina-producing to attempt to discuss anything with someone who, like Humpty-Dumpty in "Through the Looking Glass," refuses to stick to what words and legal concepts mean. That makes debate impossible. That makes logic impossible. In your first three responses, you scored a zero in honestly agreeing on terms and accuracy of definition.
1) Although it doesn't matter to the larger issue, your use of "ethicist" is so broad as to be meaningless, though it is consistent with your other uses of words and concepts.

I think we're still at a level of miscommunication on this one. My use of 'ethicist' is pulled right from the dictionary. I'm sorry that the term in its common(rather than professional) usage is so broad, like 'artist' or 'philosopher,' but I certainly meant no disrespect to your profession, which I think I tried to make clear. My only point, which I'm sure you must accept, is that I wasn't deliberately misrepresenting myself. I pointed you directly to my blog, which contains a precise, accurate profile, and for those who would dig deeper I have mentioned my actual profession on a couple of occasions. I was merely referring to a description of my interests, since in fact I spend a considerable amount of time thinking about and discussing issues of ethics.

I think anyone who examines my posts through our entire discussion will find I have stuck to my same usages/definitions of terms throughout. If your impression was otherwise please understand that this is not the case. I have remained very consistent in my own position throughout. What you have observed is merely my feeble attempts to explain that singular position in a manner which will not be misunderstood.

2) The Canadian Courts have NOT declared file-sharing "legal." That is not what the opinion about file-sharing software said. The opinion inviolved whether software used by others for file-sharing was implicated when it was so used. It's a bad opinion as it is, but it still doesn't "clarify" the legality of file-sharing. And copying an entire book by photocopy is as illegal in Canada as it is in the U.S.

I think I've failed to clarify myself properly here. According to most people who know significantly more about the law than I do, the decision does in fact deem file-sharing legal. To clarify: this does not mean that certain actions taken with the shared files do not then constitute copyright infringement. The ruling is as to the actual act of sharing files which might contain copyrighted information on your computer with other people over the internet.

Using your photocopy analogy, downloading a copyrighted book and then printing it out on your computer(maybe even to sell to someone else), which corresponds to the photocopying of a book, would in fact be illegal. It would not be illegal, however, to merely fileshare(downloading and uploading encompassed) the book. This is much more akin to putting the book in the photocopier and pressing the button that converts the book to digital information, but not actually putting paper through the machine.

Once copyrighted material is on your computer, there are in fact many things you can do with it which do not constitute infringement since at that point it is not yet considered distributed. You could, for example take songs which you have downloaded and burn them to a cd, which is legal in Canada because when you buy cds you pay a copy levy which is intended to cover any losses artists may allegedly incur because of this practice.

Another thing you could do with the material prior to distributing it in some form would be to use it in a manner appropriate under "fair use" legislation as a part of a new work of art or to quote it for purposes of review.

This is what I mean when I say that in Canada filesharing is legal. The people I've talked to seem fairly clear on the above points. It's possible of course that they're wrong, but it seems to me your objection to my pronouncement may have been based on a slightly different interpretation, i.e. something similar to the idea that in Canada we can just do whatever we want with copyrighted material. Am I right?

3) No lawyer, no ethicist, no educated person that I have asked about your very strange definition of theft agrees with it. That is because it is nonsense. There are so many kinds of theft that do not involve a physical removal that thinking them up would be a good parlor game. You are not a lawyer, my friend, give it up; I am, but you shouldn't have to be a lawyer to figure out that taking music that belongs to one owner and duplicating it for one's own use without permission, license or fee is stealing. Similarly, while the person sneaking into the theater would be committing trespass whether he watched the show of not, when he watched the show with out paying for it, THAT IS STEALING TOO!

Again, we're getting caught up on terminology, which is what I tried to head off in my response by clarifying what I meant. I could care less about how different people define the word 'theft' or 'stealing' or whatever. I'm talking about the concept that we all agree is wrong. Call it klajsghlk if you want, but when someone has property and another person takes it away so they no longer have it, we all agree that action is wrong. The reason I have included this point is that the entertainment industry is working hard to equate klajsghlk with filesharing, which is totally inaccurate and misleading. The action of duplicating something someone else has or has designed is very different both in implementation and in how society as a whole is inclined to view it, as I tried to point out in the way our copyright and patent laws are defined, which treat abstract ideas differently than physical property already, with 'rights' on exclusivity that run for a very brief period of time and then expire, which is not how we view property at all. With regards to society, I think it's safe to say that many people see this form of legislation as an expression of economic incentive rather than the protection of an inalienable right to micromanage particular abstract concepts because one holds a particular piece of paper.

To clarify the point, it's often easier to step away from the new and sometimes confusing digital world and look at a simple example:


A small village on the shores of a lake subsists entirely on fishing. Unfortunately, they are not a very advanced society and fish by wading out into the water and grabbing fish by their hands. Thus, despite the bountiful fish everywhere, they have to spend every waking moment fishing to break even.

One day, a slightly-more-clever-than-the-rest fellow is walking along the shore procrastinating from his fishing when he comes across a fish skeleton lying in the sand. There is only one kind of fish in his area, and their skeletons are an incredibly common sight. This time, however, he notices something: one of the bones on this skeleton is curved with a slight barb on the end. He thinks to himself: "if I were to convince a fish by means of some sort of bait to clamp down on this interesting shape with its mouth, it would get caught!" and right then and there he invents the fishhook.

The man calls a huge meeting of the surrounding area, telling everyone he has important news. He explains to all the people his incredible new invention. The best part, he tells everyone, is that the necessary materials for the fishing apparatus can be found literally lying on the ground all over the place. However, the man also makes a demand of all these people: every time they, or their children, or their friends, or anyone they tell, makes a fishhook using the method he has invented, they must give him 50 fish since it was his idea.


Now, this example seems ridiculous: obviously the man has no inherent right to demand payment for the use of his idea when these fish skeletons are in ready supply all over the ground.

However, it may have been that some time previous to this the town elders got together to address the problem of how inefficient their fishing was, and in order to encourage new ideas, they promised that if someone came up with a new and different way of catching fish, everyone in their village would pay that person 5 fish every time they used the idea. Now, it's a different story. The town made a promise, which they now have to keep. One can clearly see that rather than upholding the man's right to manage an abstract idea he has come up with as if it were his own property, the town was merely offering an incentive to encourage much-needed innovation.

What if, however, another town had met at the same time and considered this option but decided it was unnecessary. In their opinion, there were so many people working at fishing with all the same resources available to them that new ideas would come up as a matter of course, and no pricey incentive was necessary to encourage them. So, in that town, they refused to honour the man's request, although many of those people presented gifts to the inventor in thanks for his work. Did this town do the man an injustice? Clearly not! The man had no inherent rights to be upheld. It was only an issue of what had been agreed to. The second town did nothing unethical.

Furthermore, what if that second town had hundreds of millions of smart, innovative people in it who were able to exchange ideas easily and who had incredible resources to work with? Would it be wise for that town to offer a pricey economic incentive for things that many people were willing to do anyway? Of course not. This is why I think our societies should adjust our own usage of such incentives as well.

It goes on and on...you say that ideas aren't property. Well, what can I say...the entire world disagrees with you, because they are right and you are wrong because the world, not you, decides what it regards as "stealing.". You seem to believe that because stealing a patent has its own term, that means it isn't stealing. Wrong again.

In fact, the laws on ideas, their buying, selling, rental, etc., in every country in the world differ from the laws on physical property. We already treat them as fundamentally different! Furthermore, the out-dated fashion in which many of these laws are expressed makes them ill-adapted to our changing world, which is why I advocate reforming these laws to express the exchange of ideas in the language of services, which more accurately and capably reflects the ways in which they are now being and will continue to be used.

I have to ask you, how well will our current laws function when computers can produce music, videos, and software from scratch? This is not very far away from reality, and our legal systems as they currently stand are not ready to deal with these new developments. Already digital technologies are making it fundamentally easier for people all over the world to produce high-quality films, music, and software. Present laws already fail to reflect the incredible amount of power in a computer which is the real cause of effective filesharing: namely that for all practical purposes with regards to software our computers are just like people who can learn skills very quickly from anyone else who knows them; with regards to music our computers are like very skilled musicians who can perform a song in exact detail after hearing it only once; and with regard to movies our computers are like skilled storytellers who can give us a whole story in all its visual detail after hearing it only once. I have posted on this topic before.

Unfortunately all of this sidetracking has meant that I actually haven't heard any feedback from you on my core idea, namely that our laws would be more consistent, adaptable, and efficient if they treated the transfer of abstract concepts as a service rather than the transfer of a product. This is the essential part of my entire outlook on the future of filesharing's legal status, and the part I am most interested in having public debate about since it is the part of the debate which can most quickly be used to improve our societies.

As for the rest, you have an infuriating technique of mounting arguments that have nothing to do with what you're arguing against, such as your arguments that breaking a law is not unethical. This isn't rocket science...it is wrong to wilfully break laws unless there is an over-riding good that comes of it...and "wanting free music" doesn't count.

What can I say? I apologise that you're infuriated by my posts, although I have to say you have a tendency to view me through a coloured lense of where you think I'm coming from. Philosophically it is entirely necessary when proposing a change in law to explain the inherent rights at stake(a clarification I think I've been careful to use) as opposed to merely the current status of the law. I haven't claimed anywhere that it is ethical to break the law. I've merely pointed out that not all things enshrined in law reflect inherent rights that we all agree upon. If I may quote from my original essay, what I want "to look at is why something is illegal in the first place."

As far as the over-riding good involved, you don't know much about me if you still think that the reason I want to promote file-sharing is "wanting free music." People who know me understand that I view technology as a tool for improving the function of our world rather than simply as a toy for my own enjoyment. I want to promote filesharing as an effective way to spread new ideas, especially throughout the developing world where people don't have the luxury of paying what to them are enormous fortunes for the privilege of using their own computers effectively. In this respect, I'm thinking not so much about music as about theoretical literature(think economics, philosophy, social structure, etc.), computer software(the possibilities are almost endless), and access to virtual markets.

Frankly, and with all respect, I cannot tell whether you are just ill-informed, have a logical deficit, are intellectually dishonest, or just slippery as hell, and at this point, I don't care. Arguing under such conditions is a waste of my time, and maybe even yours. But you may have a career in politics.

Again, thanks for being civil, keep blogging, don't give up your interest in ethics...but this argument is a loser, and maintaining that it isn't approaches delusion. I can't argue with delusions, and I'm not qualified to treat them.


I know you can't, and until you can tell that I'm none of those things I fear you will be unable to understand the perspective I'm putting forward. If there's any way that you can step past the image you have of a non-serious, illogical, spoiled, selfish little kid, I would really appreciate it. I'm very serious in my rigour; I try my absolute best, and typically with good effect, to be as logical as possible, almost to a fault; and I'm brutally honest with myself intellectually, very willing to change my position immediately as new information and perspectives are made available to me. If there's any way you can understand that, I would really encourage you to reread my writings from this perspective. I think you'll find I'm anything but the person you have made me out to be. I'm sure you're very aware that in an online environment where verbal and nonverbal cues are lacking, it can be very difficult to grasp something as tricky as character, but if you can find it in yourself to put out the extremely large effort to do so, I really think we could accomplish a lot in our discussion.

I know you said you won't be replying any further here, but from what little I already know of you I think there's a part of you which desperately wants to continue. It's the part that says you've never seen another filesharer like this one before, and you're unlikely to have a chance to discuss filesharing with one on these terms again. If you can slow down, take a deep breath, and quietly review my writing without allowing a sense of frustration to rear up when you see things that on the surface resemble all those other things that have so frustrated you in the past, I just know this exchange can change from something frustrating into something incredibly useful.


sincerely,
Jeffery Coleman

Monday, December 26, 2005

Filesharing: the debate part 1

I have been trying to decide whether to post Jack Marshall's responses in piecemeal, responding to each section, or in one large block with my responses after it. I think I have hit upon a compromise: I will post a link to his article so that it can be read in its entirety first, which I suggest you all do, and then I will break it up and respond to it here. That way, we avoid the confusion of having everything quoted twice and making the post much longer than necessary.

Jack's article appears here.

Here is my response, section by section:


Open Letter to a File Sharer
(12/15/2005)

A correspondent on the Ethics Scoreboard Forum who described himself as an ethicist referred the Scoreboard to his blogged arguments that file-sharing...acquiring copyrighted music over the internet without paying for it...was ethical. After reviewing the longer of two articles he referenced, the Scoreboard offers the following response:

Dear File-Sharer:

When I first read your post on the Forum, my written response was that I had yet to see an ethical analysis that supported file-sharing, and that I was eager to read your essay on the topic. Now that I have read your piece, I am absolutely convinced: I still haven't seen an ethical analysis that supported file-sharing. What you have provided is a self-serving and breath-takingly flawed argument that is not grounded in ethics, logic, research, facts, common sense, or even accurate observations.

[Before I expand on all this, I have to inject a comment. You referred to yourself in your message as "an ethicist." That's a bit of a stretch, don't you think? You are 20 years old, according to your blog, and presumably a student. There is no evidence that you teach ethics, have been published on the topic (other than your own blog), lecture on ethics or have ever been paid a penny to render an ethical analysis of anything. This doesn't affect the validity of your analysis...it is what it is...but honestly, referring to yourself as "an ethicist," which is a profession, is a bit like saying you're "a dog breeder" because your Golden Retriever had puppies. Misrepresenting yourself is never a good beginning to an ethics discussion.]


I won't spend long on this, since as you say it doesn't affect the validity of my analysis, but I think it is important to clarify for the sake of our mutual respect that I wasn't trying to misrepresent myself. I use the term 'ethicist' in the same sense as most dictionaries, i.e.

Source: The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition
Copyright © 2000 by Houghton Mifflin Company.
Published by Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved.


Main Entry: eth·i·cist
Pronunciation: 'eth-&-s&st
Function: noun
: one who specializes in or is very concerned about ethics


Source: Merriam-Webster's Medical Dictionary, © 2002 Merriam-Webster, Inc.


ethicist

n : a philosopher who specializes in ethics [syn: ethician]


I use the term in the same sense I would use 'philosopher' to refer to people who have never been paid to lecture, speak, etc. I did not intend to refer to the profession, with regards to which I would say that the small number of ethicists who are able to sustain themselves financially on the sole basis of their ethics are very fortunate and to be applauded, in the same fashion that I would appreciate an artist who was able to sustain him or herself financially on the sole basis of his or her art. For those interested, although I am also and always a student, I am currently employed as the Winnipeg representative of a wine marketing company. See more about that at www.finewinesmanitoba.com


Your essay is entitled "The Ethics of File-Sharing," though a more accurate title would be, "The Excuses of a File-Sharer." You state at the beginning that that is indeed what you are, and frankly, it explains a lot. The essay is not a dispassionate and open-minded examination by someone inquiring into the ethical implications of a new behavioral phenomenon. It is a retroactive attempt at justification by someone who has been doing something wrong and fully intends to keep doing so without wanting to invest in the inconvenience of a squawking conscience. In other words, you begin with a personal bias and an interest in the outcome. It shows.


Again, I must respond not because I think it has any bearing on the topic at hand, but because I think it would better promote a good rational exchange if we can both maintain our respect for the other party. For the record, I am a recent file-sharer and formed my position on the ethics of the matter prior to engaging in the practice, which I also did not do before the Canadian courts had clarified the legality of the matter. The reason I have posted these ideas here is not because they are newly formed, but because I think many other people would benefit from the discussion of this very relevant topic. As I mentioned at the beginning of my first post, the reason I posted was because I found the position "I know it's wrong but I still do it" to be far too common and totally unacceptable.

I am certain that these first two points of yours were genuine mistakes given the limited information available to you, Jack, but in the future I think it would better behoove both of us to focus on the topic at hand instead of on the 'topicee' and hopefully we can thereby avoid having our rational discussion descend to an exchange of ad hominem attacks which are entirely irrelevant to the topic at hand. I think we can both agree that a true statement is true even if pronounced by the devil himself, and a false one false even if spoken by the wisest sage ever to walk the earth. Furthermore, I think we will be best capable of obtaining a synthesis of our positions into a stronger whole (either by me accepting yours, or by you accepting mine, or some combination of the above) if we can maintain a proper respect for each other both in our postings and in our own personal opinions because this will allow us to view the actual discussion at hand instead of colouring it with our own misconceptions of the other person. I have seen far too many discussions between rational, intelligent people collapse into name-calling and wild accusations which are not the least bit relevant or helpful to the discussion.


Your essay is divided into ten arguments for the ethical nature of file sharing, four "myths" and six "realities." I must admit that if I had not agreed to review your article, the first section, "Myth #1: File-sharing is stealing," would have provoked me to stop reading after the first paragraph.

File-sharing is obviously stealing, and the only way you "prove" that it isn't is by using a definition of stealing that has no moorings to reality:

"Before the digital age, stealing was cut and dried. If you took something from someone else that you had no right or legitimate reason to take, you were stealing. How could you verify if someone had stolen something from someone else? If the accused had the item and the owner of it did not, then it had been stolen. It was that simple. So when the digital world came around, what changed? The answer is nothing. This is still the way we can tell if something has been stolen. If the owner of the thing still has it, then it obviously hasn't been stolen.


This description has a teeth-jarring logical pot-hole: it ends up using "the way we tell if something has been stolen" as an element of the act itself. But this is not so. There are many, many situations in which something is stolen but the owner would not necessarily be able to tell that he had been robbed. The owner of well or a stream may never discover that someone is stealing his water: there is still water for his use, and the finite amount of the property is not known. A movie-goer who sneaks into a theater without paying for a ticket has stolen his viewing of the film, yet the film is still available to others and the theater owner may never be aware of the theft. Certainly the film's investors, the actors and the studio that made it won't, and they may have lost a portion of the unpaid ticket price...


If you persist in the position that "File-sharing is obviously stealing" then it will be difficult to have a rational debate since you have essentially defined filesharing to be unethical without considering what it actually is. Stealing as we typically observe it is a simple and obvious act where one person has property and another person takes it, thereby depriving them of it. By contrast, filesharing is copying of property, an act which functions in a totally different way. It is essential for you to even understand my position that we differentiate the idea of the 'stealingness'(in the sense that most people use it, the taking of physical property) of filesharing from the 'ethicalness' of filesharing(which may be an entirely different issue, and on which you still may have a good argument). This is the real issue, so let's not get hung up on terminology.

That said, I don't consider any of your examples to effectively support your position. If someone owns a well or a stream, assuming that they own the water in the well or stream, and someone takes that water, then they have stolen the water, and it is no longer there. They have not stolen the usage of the well or the usage of the stream. One might ask to clarify, is it theft if a person lowers a bucket into someone else's empty well and comes up with nothing, or if a person dips their bucket into someone else's stream and muddies the water but pulls their bucket out without taking any water? Clearly not. The person who lowers their bucket into an empty well may be trespassing, and the person who muddies their neighbour's stream may be vandalising, but if neither comes away with property that the owner now doesn't have, it isn't stealing as we would typically define it.

In the case of the unpaying movie-goer, by entering an establishment not his own without following the terms of that establishment, he is trespassing, not stealing. One might also argue that the theatre provided him a service by displaying the film, and was not paid for services rendered, which is the breaking of a service contract or agreement for services to be rendered. If the unpaying movie-goer had a fake ticket, then he was guilty of fraud. If he claimed he already had a ticket he was guilty of lying. All this things are unethical, but none of them is stealing.

We must also be careful not to become sidetracked on the issue of whether the owner is aware of the act or not. If I have a car out back and someone takes it but I don't notice, it has clearly already been stolen. This is not something I dispute. My claim is not with regards to our awareness of whether the stolen property is still present, but with regards to whether it is present at all. In this case, the car is definitely gone, and thus theft has occurred.


...In the case of file sharing, as it happens, there is a valid argument that the owner doesn't still have what was stolen, which was his right to dictate the terms under which the particular user (the file-sharer) could benefit from his creation. But whether it is the creation that is being stolen or the right to use it, it is still stealing.

This is also not a standard usage of the term 'stolen.' The typical legal and common term for someone's legal rights not being respected is 'infringement.' If the right to dictate these terms had been stolen, then future 'infringements' on the terms would not be considered illegal since there was no longer a right to dictate them(this right had been stolen). In reality, however, this is not the case. In the United States, for example, where filesharing is illegal, one individual can be prosecuted multiple times for downloading the same file on different computers, and can also be charged with downloading the same file again even if already charged previously for the same act.

One might ask, what if the owner is not given the right to dictate such terms by the laws of his particular jurisdiction? In that case, what exactly has occurred? You will note, of course, that my own position is that there is no inherent right to dictate terms on intellectual 'property' or ideas, although it may or may not be economically useful to provide such an opportunity to the residents of a jurisdiction.


Did you consider consulting a dictionary before putting into print your strange definition of stealing? Here's one legal dictionary's definition of "theft," which is the technical term for stealing:

theft n.: the generic term for all crimes in which a person intentionally and fraudulently takes personal property of another without permission or consent and with the intent to convert it to the taker's use (including potential sale).

I see nothing in this definition that says the owner must notice the property stolen is missing or not still have use of it himself.

Again, the noticing or not noticing is a red herring. As far as having use of the property goes, that would centre around what one means by 'convert.' If, for example, a Muslim converts to Atheism, they cannot still be a Muslim, or if ice is converted to water, it cannot still be ice. Typically one would thus interpret the above definition to mean that the owner has lost use of the property.

This definition accurately describes file-sharing. So does this one, from Merriam Webster:

theft n.: an unlawful taking of property

Is it stealing if you take my picture off the internet and use it in ads for file-sharing software without paying me or getting my permission? Absolutely, but I still have my boyish good looks. My image is my property no matter how many times it is duplicated and used this way, and taking it is theft. So much, therefore, for this argument of yours:

"...If the owner of the thing still has it, then it obviously hasn't been stolen. But what if someone else has it that didn't have it before? The answer is simple: they didn't steal it, they copied it. It's a completely different act. It may be unethical for other reasons we shall later discuss, but it is a different act from stealing."


Since of course 'unlawful' is included in Webster's definition this is a measure of legality rather than ethics, and by that definition filesharing would not be 'theft' in jurisdictions where it is legal. Which is entirely, of course, my point.

As far as your picture goes, I would of course reply that your picture has definitely not been stolen. The law would support me on this, as a person who did this would not be charged with stealing, but rather with a form of copyright infringement, depending on how the picture was used. Your picture is in fact an excellent example, since it is copied to every computer which views your website, although none of them 'steal' it from you. Your issue is not that it is copied, but the particular way in which it is. Clearly, when something is stolen we do not nitpick about how it was stolen in determining whether an unethical act has occurred. There is no right way to steal something, even if by some loophole the person cannot be prosecuted under the law.


In order to support your argument, you have simply devised a narrow definition of property that isn't used in this society...and that's how we define theft, by what we define as property. What you define as property is factually incorrect...


This is, again, my entire point. We define what property is, and as far as consistency goes, it would be inconsistent to define ideas and purely digital representations as property. We should more accurately define these things as services, which is what they really are since they take things that are already ours (our minds, our computers, etc.) and modify them in their configurations rather than adding anything to them. This is a service, just like getting your car modified from a less useful to a more useful state, like a mechanic does, or getting a pile of raw materials modified from a less useful to a more useful state, like a builder does. If a mechanic works for you for free, do you steal something from the person who taught him to fix cars? This makes no sense whatsoever.


...Continuing on from the last paragraph...

...This is clear from the way we view things other than file-sharing in society. For example, in architecture the vast majority of design elements are copied from other locations in history and in the present. Everything from the silverware you eat with to the furniture you sit in to the light bulbs you light your home with has been copied from somewhere. This is the mechanism by which good ideas are spread throughout society. And what about non-physical items, like ideas or methods? Every time you quote a famous person, or teach someone else something that was taught to you, or tell a story that was told to you, you are copying an idea. Again, this is the mechanism by which good ideas are spread, and it's an act totally unlike stealing...


Ah...so much misinformation, so little time! One can indeed ethically copy from great works of architecture because they are centuries old and the architects are long dead, but use the original design of a living architect and you will find yourself in court, because it's stealing. If you copy an original Valentino dress for your own use, it's also stealing: just try wearing it on "the red carpet." If an artist friend copies an abstract Bruce Gray painting for you to hang in your house, you've robbed artist Gray of the proceeds he would receive from a licensed copy or the original; you've robbed him. If you are choreographing a professional production of "Grease" and use Patricia Birch's choreography without her permission, you have stolen it, and she will get a court judgement against you for its value.


None of these are examples of stealing. These are all examples of copyright infringement, which is totally different. If our ideas were our property in the same sense that physical objects are, why does their ownership expire, and in many cases, do so before their author has done so? When you have owned a car for a given number of years can it suddenly cease to be your property? Not unless it was a rental, in which case it was never yours to begin with. The reason our governments typically define a brief period in which one person has the exclusive control over a particular idea is merely economic incentive. These economic incentives are not declarations of property. They are declarations of an exclusive right to provide certain services, which is my entire point. Clearly copyright infringement protection, as an economic incentive, is not an issue of ethics, but rather of legality. With regards to law, I am much more interested in our decision as to whether or not we should keep such economic incentives in place or remove them. With regards to ethics, however, the mere fact that our government has chosen to espouse something does not mean alternatives would be unethical if our governments chose to espouse them. This is in fact what I advocate: that our governments select an alternative method than these economic incentives to encourage innovation. All of this has everything to do with economics and nothing to do with ethics.

As for your light bulb example, you appear to be blissfully unaware of the concept of a patent, which legally establishes a property right in an original idea, an invention. For as long as a patent lasts, nobody can copy an originator's invention without permission or paying for the privilege, though people try. It's called stealing a patent...patent infringement. Similarly, your charming belief that intangible ideas are not property would be quite a surprise to the thousands of people who hold intellectual property rights, the drafters of the laws that protect their ideas, and the lawyers in the billion dollar intellectual property protection industry.


Patent infringement--correct. Stealing--incorrect. Different act. Patents are also economic incentives rather than reflections of ethical realities, and essentially establish an exclusive right to provide a service rather than a declaration of the ownership of property. Again, if patents reflected the existence of property, why would that exclusive right be able to expire when the holder of the patent has not? The answer is that patents are not proof of property, they are even more proof that we should consider digital representations and ideas as services rather than property. Again, however, these are economic rather than ethical questions. I might add that I myself am a possessor of significant intellectual 'property' and do not mind the economic incentives offered by my government which allows me exclusivity on performance of certain services. I just don't think I have any inherent right to those incentives, and think that our laws would be in better shape if they were more clear about the differences between services and property, with transfer of intangible ideas being clearly defined as a service rather than a transfer of property.

Now, you may say, as some have, that this shouldn't be, that ideas should not be property. And that is a perfectly respectable idea, except that the concept of property is defined by our society, not individuals. The native American tribes didn't believe that land was property. Some of the Hippies in the Sixties didn't believe anything (except maybe drugs) should be property: ever hear of Abby Hoffman's Steal This Book? You are certainly free to start a society in which ideas and music and art aren't property, or where turnips or LEGOS or cats aren't property, for that matter. In that society, these things can't be stolen. Go ahead, establish it, call it "File-sharinglandia;" see if anyone wants to live in it. Good luck to you. But while you're in this society, you are not free to live by definitions of property that are counter to practice, tradition, and law. File-sharing is stealing, and stealing is wrong. Your definition of stealing, in which file-sharing is something else, exists only in your mind.


If ethics are defined by our society's practice, than filesharing is clearly de facto ethical because of the large number of people who do it. Clearly a significant segment of our society does not agree that filesharing shouldn't be practiced, and as far as a land where filesharing is allowed, I don't call it "File-sharinglandia," I call it "Canada." Tradition is fairly useless to any rational person, since traditions can be very, very wrong. All that leaves is law, which is my main concern. I am concerned that our laws are not currently set up in a consistent, rigid fashion which reflects the opinions of people in society, which is free from self-contradiction, and which will be able to continue effectively in a changing world, namely, a largely digital one. What I advocate legally is to redefine the transfer of intangible ideas as services, and then implement our copyright and patent laws as economic incentive programs, which I believe is legally stronger and will prevent such possible pitfalls as a man being prosecuted for rotating his tires in the same fashion as his neighbour, or for having a doorknob which turns the same way. Clearly, this fundamental difference is already reflected in the legal prevention of the patenting/copyrighting of 'obvious' things, although this is a terribly hard to nail down definition and is thus a potential problem with our current legal system which would be solved by my modification of its structure. Thus my definition of stealing is reflected in the reality of both the real world and current law.

I can clearly skip Myth #2, which you agree with.

The reason I bring up Myth #3 is because many people will accept actions which are equivalent to filesharing as ethical if they are made more difficult. This is not a straw man. This is an observed reality. It does not appear to be your position, and thus I won't labour the point here.


Take "Myth #4: copyRight, copyWrong" (cute title!), for example. Right off the bat, you make an assertion that is just plain ethically wrong:

...But more importantly, simply because something is illegal does not make it inherently unethical. What we have to look at is why something is illegal in the first place.


Fascinating. Since conduct is made illegal because a society decides that it is in some way damaging to individuals in the society or society itself, what legally prohibited acts are ethical? I suppose there are a few, such as some victimless crimes, but as discussed above, stealing property, as in file-sharing, isn't victimless. And you miss one very basic point: breaking the law is itself unethical. It is a violation of a promise, through your social contract with your country, province, and town, to abide and respect rules of conduct, or pay the penalty of breaking them.

You appear to have missed the word "inherently." Laws are whatever we make them, and thus we could easily redefine the laws on digital information transfer, as Canada has done. My point was that laws are not necessarily reflections of inherent realities. They reflect the decisions lawmakers have made. If this were not the case, it would always be unethical to change the laws on something, which we do all the time in both Canada and the United States. This is why there must be a clear differentiation between inherent ethics and legality.

As far as the entire section on Canadian law, I have this to say:

Canadian law is not the sum of whatever law firms choose to put on their websites. It is the sum of our statutes and the rulings of our judges. My clarification on current law is pulled from the very ruling that you noticed and wrote about which started our exchange. If you disagree with this position, you can take it up with the judge who ruled thus, but because of his ruling this is the way Canadian law currently is. It is a little ironic that you included the photocopier example since the ruling specifically went the way it did so that photocopiers being placed in libraries would not have to be made illegal.

The rest of your essay, the so-called "realities," descend into typical rationalizations and occasionally non-sequiturs...


The second portion of my essay does not consist of rationalisations. The shift from 'myths' to 'realities' represents the shift from my argument on the ethics of filesharing to my expression of the logical consequences of my argument, so of course if you do not accept my argument you would not accept this portion of my essay, which is to be expected. If you perceived this second half as part of my argument, you would of course then consider it insufficient argumentation, since it is not intended to be argumentation at all.


There may yet be an ethical argument for file-sharing to be made. You're articulate and thoughtful; maybe you'll be the one to make it. But in order to do that, you'll have to do the work of acquiring real facts, learning about real laws, and applying disciplined analysis. For now, your argument for file-sharing is no more or less than "It's free, it's convenient, and I want to do it."

It isn't ethical, but it's the best you have.

Sincerely,

Jack Marshall, President, ProEthics, Ltd.


I think you can now see that I would be the last person to make the argument that "It's free, it's convenient, and I want to do it" and that my position is in fact more thoroughly grounded in ethics than you thought.

Thank you for your interest, Jack, and I hope you will respond to my clarifications if you have the time.

sincerely,
Jeffery Coleman

Filesharing: the debate!

First, I want to get everybody on the same page, so I will include all the correspondence that led to an exchange of ideas.

To begin with, I read this and posted this:

Posted by Jeffery Coleman (24.79.84.77) on December 09, 2005 at 09:41:41:

I found this article looking back on the site, and was quite surprised at it's one-sided take on filesharing. The author seems unaware that many ethicists have come down on the other side of the ethical debate here as well. I happen to be one of them. I've outlined the reasons why here:

http://fugitivethoughts.blogspot.com/2005/12/filesharing-ethics-revisited.html

and more extensively here:

http://fugitivethoughts.blogspot.com/2005/09/ethics-of-filesharing.html

It seems this is a very split issue; that is, I have met people who come down very heavily on each side, but not many who are willing to consider a move to 'the other side' for any reason. Furthermore, there doesn't seem to have been a lot of public debate on this topic at all. So, if any of you share the views of the author here, and are willing to contribute to the debate, I'd love to have you comment on the ideas I've posted.

sincerely,
Jeffery Coleman


Then, I received this reply:


Posted by Jack Marshall (202.131.253.182) on December 10, 2005 at 02:11:20:

In Reply to: "Canada's File-Sharing Surrender" posted by Jeffery Coleman on December 09, 2005 at 09:41:41:

Jeffrey: Thanks for the post and the refernces. For some reason the internet can't find blogspot out here (I'm in Mongolia on a legal ethics assignment) so I can't read your pieces. I will when I get back (soon) and comment here. And I hope someone else does as well. For some reason, readers only seem to debate with, me and not with each other. If we can change that convention, I'll be very happy.
I admit to being eager to read a coherent defense of file-sharing that is based on ethical rather than non-ethical (it's inevitable; it can't be stopped; everyone's going to do it anyway; those music guys make too much money; music should belong to everyone)considerations.


Which I was very happy to read, since as many of you know I am also frustrated with the 'inevitability,' 'they make too much money,' etc. non-ethical 'arguments' for filesharing.

and then, later, this:


Posted by Jack Marshall (208.226.48.103) on December 12, 2005 at 23:47:29:

In Reply to: "Canada's File-Sharing Surrender" posted by Jeffery Coleman on December 09, 2005 at 09:41:41:

Jeff: I read your longer article, and you should look for the long article I have written in response to appear on the home page very soon. It does not use your name.


Which of course, really intrigued me with the 'it does not use your name' clause. Then, I was off to spend christmas with family. As that time comes to a close and I have now had a chance to read that article, I will post it and my response to it in my next post.

Finally!

Finally, I've found someone interested in discussing the ethics of filesharing, although their first response seems very dismissive of the very idea that one could form an ethical position which supports filesharing.

Nonetheless, they appear willing to discuss the matter rationally and carefully, so I will be posting our first exchange here shortly. You can expect these exchanges to get rather long, but I hope that anyone currently considering the ethics of this issue themselves will read through both sides carefully and then add their own comments as they like.

This person comes from the site ethicsscoreboard.com so check out that site for a lot of content from a similar perspective and to get an idea where they're coming from.

Thursday, December 15, 2005

Ye old carolers

We've all seen them: the quaint, picturesque groups of carolers dressed in the full costume of 17th century british peasants. They stand in perfect 'choir' formation and sing beautiful christmas songs.

But what, you may ask, do these carolers do when they have finished caroling for the day and it is time to go back to their 21st century homes? Do they disband and head for their suv's and minivans? Do they slip into a phonebooth and pull off a miraculous time-shifting transformation?

Earlier this evening as I walked through the Portage Place shopping centre, I chanced upon a group of carolers in just such limbo, stuck between their two realities. Having apparently finished their carols for the day, they were wandering around the mall window-shopping. As I passed them, they paused to look at some t-shirt designs displayed in a clothing store window. Whether it was force of habit, some form of conditioning, pure chance, or simply artistic dedication to their performance, they came to a halt in exact choral formation without seemingly paying any attention to it.

As they stood their conversing in hushed tones about t-shirts with designs like 'Pot Nation' and 'Ask my wife--she's always right!' I marveled at their juxtaposed realities. A given passerby might equally well mistake them for time travelers as identify them as modern-day winnipegers browsing through the mall. For a moment, they seemd childlike in their blissful ignorance of the startling reality they presented.

Then one of them suggested they head over to Tim Hortons. "F* that! I'm going home'" was the answer, and the paradox dissolved as the temporal shift was completed and the group dismantled.

Good old Winnipeg.

Wednesday, December 14, 2005

They call it stealing

I found a wonderful site which, unlike most of the entertainment industry campaigns, seems legitimately interested in developing a workable ethics of filesharing. You can find them at:

http://theycallitsharing.com

I suggest you read through their website before continuing.

Using the 'contact us' form on their site, I posted the following response to their website:

----
Hi,

Your position on filesharing is a lot more thought-through than most that I've heard. Clearly, you're interested in having concise and accurate reasons for your stance. I have to say, though, that some of your arguments are not sound.

For example, a large part of your argument is based on the fact that musicians put a lot of hard work into their music. Unfortunately, although this argument pulls on my heartstrings, that doesn't mean it's a legitimate reason that filesharing is wrong. Just because someone works hard on something doesn't mean they have a right to get paid for it. I have many artist friends who have worked very hard but have not been financially successful, with many of their pieces remaining unsold. Have they been wronged by the people who did not buy their art? No, because there is no such thing as a 'right to get paid.' In order to get paid artists also have to convince their patrons to support them.

Another portion of your argument suggests that stealing has occurred because the artists and record companies do not make any money when a song is downloaded. Again, however, part of the picture is missing. There is no right to be profitable. Every day businesses fail and go bankrupt. This is not neccesarily because someone has wronged them. It may simply be that they failed to understand the market, or that the service they provided was replaced by a more advanced one. For example, when the automobile was invented it put horse and buggy retailers out of business in short order. This is not because it did something wrong to them, but simply because it was a better technology. In the reality of the digital world, there may be better technologies and business models for how to make money.

The problem with your position on filesharing is that it fails to understand the incredible transformation that has occurred in the world through the digital revolution. The world is different now, and some businesses may have to adapt. In the digital world, where one person can share any music they have on their computer with anyone else, the whole world is like a big open courtyard. When any musician plays there(ie releases their music on the open market), everyone can hear the music all over the courtyard. It's not wrong for them to hear it. It's just the way the sound can propogate through the air without costing the musician anything extra(free distribution on the internet). So how do you make money in this environment? The street performer has the answer: put out your hat or your guitar case. You have to convince people to give you their money. Sure, you probably won't make millions this way, but maybe that age is over. Maybe the car has replaced the horse. Maybe the indie performer with a paypal 'donate' link on his website will replace the superstar with their huge record label and advertising agency and agent. Technology is making good music cheaper to produce all the time.

In the digital world, every computer is like a skilled musician who can replay any song after hearing it only once. In such an environment, human musicians who originate music have to find new ways to operate. It might be tough to adapt, but the fact is, the world changes from time to time. And in the end, music will be better for it, because instead of being overproduced and overhyped and fake and marketed, it will be genuine art right from the artist.

I would like to cordially invite you to enter into a discussion on this topic at my blog, fugitivethoughts.blogspot.com

I think this is an important issue for us all to discuss and come to agreement on, so that we can build laws into our various legal systems which reflect the way the world actually works and thereby allow us to maintain a functional society.

See you there!

sincerely,
Jeffery Coleman
----

Hopefully, someone from there will be interested in discussing the issue here.

Monday, December 05, 2005

Filesharing Ethics Revisited

Alright, so I didn't get any kind of comments on my last stab at filesharing. That might have had something to do with its length. Here's a much simpler way of putting my position which I think is a little more approachable, and hopefully this time we'll get some responses.

Digital anything(software, video, music) is a service, not a product.

That's it. What we are used to thinking of as coherent digital 'objects' because of how our computers are set up are in fact just terms we have for ways our computers are configured, and configuring them as such is a service, so as long as the person who provides it doesn't charge us we should feel ethically vindicated. Thus by analogy from computers to humans, with regards to software our computers are just like people who can learn skills very quickly from anyone else who knows them; with regards to music our computers are like very skilled musicians who can perform a song in exact detail after hearing it only once; and with regard to movies our computers are like skilled storytellers who can give us a whole story in all its visual detail after hearing it only once, none of which are unethical, and in none of these cases would we expect the originator to be able to micromanage these other skilled individuals.

In the end, I guess it all comes down to the 'if it's easy, it's wrong' thinking.

Tuesday, November 29, 2005

Confusing your peers 101

Quote of the week:

"Mackey's axiom system is somewhat unsatisfactory though, since it assumes that the partially ordered set is actually given as the orthocomplemented closed subspace lattice of a separable Hilbert space."

For those of you who don't know what that means, memorise it and slip it into a conversation sometime.

For those of you who do: shame, shame, shame!

For those of you who encounter this line at your next cocktail party, the safe response is something like, "Yeah, that set is so unorthocomplemented!"

Cheers!